Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Encyclopedia of Indian Philosophies v7.c53.3

The Encyclopedia of Indian Philosophies v7.c53.3

Language
English

v7.c53.3

Considerable controversy reigns among modern scholars concerning the *Dhātukāya*’s chronological position among the Sarvāstivāda Abhidharma materials. Kogen Mizuno has divided the seven canonical texts into three groups, early, middle and late. He places in the first group the *Saṅgītiparyāya*, *Dharmaskandha* and *Prajñaptiśāstra*; the *Vijñānakāya* and *Dhātukāya* in the second; and the *Prakaraṇapāda* and *Jñānaprasthāna* in the last group.⁵ Hajime Sakurabe advocates instead two major divisions, with the second group divided into three subdivisions: first, the *Saṅgītiparyāya* and *Dharmaskandha*; and second, (a) the *Vijñānakāya*, *Dhātukāya* and *Prajñapti*; (b) *Prakaraṇa*; (c) *Jñānaprasthāna*.⁶ Ryogon Fukuhara, the scholar who has made the most exhaustive study of the Sarvāstivāda canonical materials, finally returns to a three-fold division in his description of the appearance of the six *pādaśāstras*: *Saṅgītiparyāya* and *Dharmaskandha* appear in his earliest group, *Prajñapti* and *Vijñānakāya* in his middle group, and *Dhātukāya* and *Prakaraṇa* in his late group.⁷ Both in structurre and content, we would expect the text to appear in later strata of material than the obviously primitive *Saṅgītiparyāya* and *Dharmaskandha*, which are both reminiscent of the *āgamas* in their approach, though a more precise determination will be virtually impossible to make.

Cites (7)