Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

Indian Philosophy v2.c24.s3.25

Indian Philosophy v2.c24.s3.25

Language
English

v2.c24.s3.25

The several topics discussed in the Nyāya Sūtra are first enunciated, then defined, and lastly examined.² Definition states the essential nature (svarūpa) of a thing so as to differentiate it from others. The function of a definition is to distinguish the thing defined from all things different from itself, with which it is likely to be confused.³ We can distinguish things without stating their respective essences. An asādhāraṇa dharma or a peculiar attribute also helps us to distinguish. The fallacies incident to definition are of three kinds: Ativyāpti, or the extension of the attribute to objects beyond the class defined, occurs in definitions which are too wide, as when we define a cow as a horned animal; Avyāpti, or limitation of the attributes to only a portion of the class defined, which occurs in definitions which are too narrow, as when we define a cow as a tawny animal; Asambhava, or the fallacy committed when the definition does not state the essential attributes of the object defined, as when we define a cow as an animal with uncloven hoofs. Definition states " a characteristic mark which applies to all things denoted by the term defined, neither more nor less." ⁴ To secure this, we may start with the genus and subsequently narrow its denotation by the express exclusion of superfluous objects, by the use of words like other than (itara), different from (bhinna).¹ This is definition by genus and difference.