A Constructive Survey of Upanishadic Philosophy c5.s4.2.5
A Constructive Survey of Upanishadic Philosophy c5.s4.2.5
- Language
- English
c5.s4.2.5
The Pythagorean doctrine of Transmigration and its Indian analogue dating so far back as the days of the Ṛigveda, the Phaedrus myth of the Charioteer and the Horses and an exactly similar myth in the Kaṭhopanishad, the representation of the idea of the Good in Plato as the Sun of the world of ideas having its counterpart in the description in the Kaṭhopanishad of the Ātman as verily the Sun who is the eye of the world and is free from all imperfections, the μὴ ὄν of Plato corresponding phonetically, philologically and even philosophically to the Māya of the Vedānta, Parmeides’s attack in Plato against the Universality of the Idea represented to a word in the famous criticism by Śaṅkara of the Naiyāyika idea of the Universal, the analogy of the Vāk in Ṛigveda to the Logos in Heracleitus, the Stoics, and Greek philosophy generally—all these could not be said to be less interesting specimens of the analogies of Greek and Indian Thought. How may we explain these cosmological, and extra-cosmological, analogies? Not by the Theory of Borrowal, for this cannot be historically proved. Nor by the Theory of Common Origin, because, in spite of the similarities, the philosophical concepts of the two lands are placed in a setting all their own, the Pythagorean theory of Numbers and the Platonic theory of Ideas being as peculiar to Greek thought, as the Upanishadic doctrine of the Turīya and the Mimāṃsaka doctrine of the Sphoṭa are peculiar to Indian thought.