A Cluster of Nyāya Flowers 5.10.21

5.10.21

codayatyākṣipati padārthānupakārasiddhayarthitārthitvaḥ taṃ prati jāgamayaṃ vāda iti | na ca śrutismṛtivirodhodāharaṇamiti | 'prājāpatyaṃ śatakṛṣṇalaṃ caruṃ nirvapedāyuṣkāmaḥ' ityādau kāryasya kṛṣṇalatāpratipādakāni tāni parasparaviruddhaśrutyudāharaṇānyeveti bhaṭṭa ācaṣṭe | tathā……lakṣaṇasya tatropakārasya darśanānniyataparimāṇā hi hemakanusmṛtiriti bhāṣyakṛtodāhṛtam, anayośca virodhe hi sarvā veṣṭitāra…… rmaṃtyādibādhāprakaraṇārambhavaiphalyaṃ svarasata evāprāptatvāt; sāṅkhyāyane brāhmaṇa etat paṭhyata iti hi sa āha evamanyodāharaṇeṣvapi | ata eva……nucodako yena yenānārthī taṃ tamevākṣepsyati | kimidamucyate sotprāsamāha | sadācārasyāpyanibaddhasya vivāhe kaṅkaṇabandhanādeḥ | vikṣipta……yāgānāmupadeśenaiva dharmavidhānamiti na 'prakṛtivad vikṛtiḥ kartavyā iti | kānicit tadavirodhyeneti | na hi śaivādau vaidikānuṣṭhānanindādvāreṇa svakīya- 5 carīyānuṣṭhānapraśaṃsā | prathamaṃ kāryeṇa dharmāḥ sambadhyante | yathākāryanupadeśa iti pakṣaśravaṇe'tra vaidikāstasyāśca vratacaryāyā yugapadanuṣṭhānāsambhavād gṛha īśvaravadvikalpo bhavi......| sambaddhāste tasyaiva na kāryāntarasya | darśapūrṇamāsakāryād aindrāgnasaparyāśīṣṭyanuṣṭhānād vṛṣṭidarśanāt saṃvāda evamihāpi viśiṣṭamantrajapādito viṣādyapā teṣāṃ vihitattvād | aindrāgnādiṣṭopadeśataḥ prāptyabhāvāt prāptisiddhayaḥ | mīmāṃsakaddaṣṭyāsmaddaṣṭyā 10 vā smṛtīnāṃ prāmāṇye yo nyāyaḥ so'trāpi mā vābhūt tathāpi prathamastastenaiva prathamaṃ sambadhyanta iti pūrvapakṣayitvā niṣphalatvādyajeḥ saphalādīnāṃ prāmāṇyaṃ kathaṃ nirvahati |