Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Classical Accounts of India c6.s6.4

The Classical Accounts of India c6.s6.4

Language
English

c6.s6.4

Now Aristobulus and Ptolemy both accompanied Alexander and were present in the battlefield Plutarch says his account is based on the description of the battle given by Alexander himself in his letters (196). How are we then to explain all these discrepancies? Arrian undertook the task of writing a comprehensive account of Alexander's Indian expedition He wisely followed the authority of two generals. Ptolemy and Aristobulus, who actually took part in the expedition Yet he simply records the different versions without any comment Being a junior contemporary of Plutarch he must have been aware of the existence of Alexander's letters containing what should be regarded as the most authentic account of his battle with Porus But he makes no reference to these letters It is difficult, therefore, to avoid the conclusion that even Arrian, not to speak of others, cannot he regarded as a critical historian, in the sense in which we understand the expression today It would, therefore, be unreasonable to attach a great value to the different accounts of the expeditions of Alexander, except on those points on which there is a general agreement