Early Buddhist Theory of Knowledge c8.204
Early Buddhist Theory of Knowledge c8.204
- Language
- English
c8.204
(225) Now, as Dr Basham has pointed out, Śīlāṅka identifies this doctrine of the Sūtrakṛtāṅga with that of the Trairāśika followers of Gosāla (*loc. cit.*). But interpreting this verse Śīlāṅka gives a different explanation of *kiddā-padosa-* from that suggested in the Pāli texts, which tries to make out that the cause is excessive debauchery (ativelaṁ hassa-khiddā-rati-dhamma-samāpannā, *loc cit.*). Śīlāṅka gives a more sublime reason for their fall, which was probably the reason that the Trairāśikas themselves would have given, namely that the eternal soul has feelings about the true religion and 'is *elated* when his religion is revered (on earth) and other religions are looked down upon and *is angry* when his own religion is despised'¹ explaining *kiddā-* and *padosa-* as this joy and anger respectively. It is possible that when the Buddha warned his disciples not to be elated when people praise his religion and not to be angry when people condemn it (Brahmajāla Sutta, D I.3, *v. infra*, 739) he was influenced by what he believed to be the plight of the Ājīvika as a result of his elation and anger about his own religion At the same time the Buddhist criticism that falling a prey to temptation was the cause of their fall may have had some basis in the Ājīvika beliefs themselves, since one of the greatest fears of the Ājīvika ascetic was that he may succumb to the caresses of 'the gods Punnabhadda and Maṇibhadda' who tempt him on the verge of death (*v.* Basham, *op cit.*, p. 257 *ff*).
Cites (1)
- Brahmajālasutta — Pāli