A History of Indian Medical Literature v2.c30.970

v2.c30.970

593 See ABI 154; J. Filliozat in L. Renou and J. Filliozat (1953): II, 150; Gulabkunverba I, 97–99; O.P. Jaggi (IV, 14); A.B. Keith (1973): 506; G. Mukhopadhyaya (HIM III, 622–624); NCC IX, 97; S.N. Sen (1971): 53; G.P. Srivastava (1954): 50; M. Winternitz (III, 546); Yādavaśarman (upodghāta, 10–11, to ed. z of the Carakasamhitā). D. Chattopadhyaya (1979: 33) is not completely convinced of Drdhabala's Kaśmīr origin, but suggests that this Kashmīrian background, if true, might explain the contempt expressed in the Carakasamhitā (I.5.29) for South Indian peoples like the Draviḍas and Āndhrakas. 594 Vrddhatrayī 32–42. 595 Vrddhatrayī 40–41. 596 Hoernle ascribed the Siddhayoga to Mādhava. 597 A.S.Ci.16.2 is related to, but not identical with Ca.Ni.3.16. 598 A.F.R. Hoernle (1908): 1005. 599 Kusumāvalī ad Siddhayoga 20.24–27. 600 A.F.R. Hoernle (1908): 1007. 601 A.F.R. Hoernle (1908a): 37–39; (1978): 3, 14. 602 A.F.R. Hoernle (1978): 12–14. 603 Cakrapāṇi ad Ca.Ci.26.129–131. Hoernle's views on Drdhabala's number of eye diseases were discussed by G. Mukhopadhyaya (HIM III, 630–633), who apparently does not agree with him, considering Mādhava to be later than Drdhabala. P.V. Sharma (1968: 339) dismisses Hoernle's claim. 604 G. Mukhopadhyaya (HIM III, 632) already rejected Hoernle's interpretation. 605 A.F.R. Hoernle (1908). 606 P.V.Sharma (1968): 328. 607 Gulabkunverba I, 100. 608 See: Bower MS. Hoernle's opinion is uncritically adopted by the Gulabkunverba team (I, 104), Jyotir Mitra (1982: 28), and O.P. Jaggi (IV.14). 609 P.V. Sharma (1970a): 73–80. The same author expressed the opinion (1992d: 195, n.99) that Drdhabala is probably later than a particular part of the Mārkaṇḍeyapurāṇa, which refers to a text in thirteen chapters that may be Caraka's Cikitsāsthāna prior to its completion by Drdhabala. This passage from the Mārkaṇḍeyapurāṇa (63.39–65), however, mentions thirteen sections of the Atharvaveda, next to the eight limbs of the āyurveda. 610 Dates assigned to Drdhabala are: earlier than the eleventh century (P. Cordier, 1899a: 3, 1901a; 80, 1912: 543; J. Filliozat in L. Renou et J. Filliozat, 1953: 150); later than Mādhava's Rugviniścaya (and Vrnda's) Siddhayoga, i.e., posterior to the seventh or eighth century (A.F.R. Hoernle, 1906a: 292, 1908: 998, 1978: 2–3; O.P. Jaggi IV, 30); ninth century (HCIP IV, 199; O.P. Jaggi, 1966: 71; O.P. Jaggi IV, 14; R.F.G. Müller, 1932: 810; 1937a: 54, 57); eighth or ninth century (S. Dasgupta, 1975: II, 426; A.B. Keith, 1973: 506; R.C. Majumdar, 1971: 222; S.N.Sen, 1971: 53; Winternitz III, 546); seventh or eighth century (Vrddhatrayī 43); sometime near the sixth century (D. Chattopadhyaya, 1979: 32); fourth or fifth century (B. Tripāṭhī's Bhūmikā, 19, to ed. ll of the Carakasamhitā); fourth century (Haridattaśarman's upodghāta, da–dha, to ed. ee of the Carakasamhitā; Jyotir Mitra, 1982: 27; P.V. Sharma: earlier part of the Gupta age, i.e., fourth century: 1970a: 67–81, 1972d: 102–103, AVI 107–113, Intr. (XIII) to ed. kk of the Carakasamhitā, 1992d: 187–188); the end of the third or the beginning of the fourth century (ABI 154–156; Gulabkunverba I, 101; NCC IX, 97); third century (Gaṇanātha Sena, 1924: I, 10–11; V. Sukla, 1977: I, 47; Yādavaśarman's upodghāta, 11, to ed. z of the Carakasamhitā); earlier than A.D. 300